I think that some of our paths are not to different and overlap on at least one topic. We both want to know how to cure Morgellons Disease.
‘I would have much rather had Dr. Wymore tell us if the DNA sequencing has already been done instead of only mentioning this to disprove a video. Does anyone else find this to be strange and sad?’ ‘I see contradictions everywhere! It’s easy, inexpensive, and accurate…… Tell me why we are all still sitting here in the dark suffering and grasping at straws daily? ???” ‘ ‘Why did I come to a public forum to look for answers rather than a foundation set up for people like me? Think about that one very hard.???????’
While one or two of your questions are likely rhetorical, I will address
the others. Here is my research update that includes failures,
dead-ends, unknowns and observations that will never be published, because no one in the research world would be interested. Some of what I am about to tell you has only been done once and until it is replicated is fairly meaningless in scientific circles. Yes, as I will discuss below, there has been DNA sequencing. No, it has not revealed the likely cause of Morgellons.
1) Individual red and blue Morgellons fibers were placed in bacterial media and cultured at body temperature. Isolates of those bacterial populations were grown on lab preparative media, blood agar, chocolate agar and a type of media that tends to support fungi better than bacteria. The bacteria were stained with various stains and observed both alive and dead. The bacteria were separated out into pure cultures (I think). PCR was performed and the amplified DNA was sent to a commercial sequencing lab to do the DNA sequencing. Two different
bacterial species were identified. They were: a) Pseudomonas putida and b) Corynebacterium efficiens. Does this identification mean anything? I do not know. Both of these can cause infections, especially in immunocompromised individuals. Both of these bacterial types are found in soil and can be found in skin.
The fact that they grew from fibers that were associated with skin makes it difficult to say if they are related to Morgellons Disease in any meaningful way, or merely normal skin contaminants.
Still, these are the only two DNA sequences to be identified so far.
2) The fibers can be dissolved in 6 molar hydrochloric acid, at 90 C. The fibers first fragment and then dissolve, much like hair.
The fibers are not touched by strong reducing agents or chemicals that are routinely used to isolate DNA (guanidinium isothyocyanate), even after sitting in the chemical for over a week. One preliminary spectroscopic analysis suggested a strong sulfur signal.
This has not yet been reproduced. A blue fiber was analyzed a little over a week ago by a collaborative chemistry lab.
This fiber was neither, cotton, cellulose nor any known textile. No definitive composition has been determined so
far. The chemical/spectroscopic analysis is an ongoing process.
3) I receive 2-15 packages of samples per week. We look at the samples in the order they come in but each sample may have 5-50 smaller packages of samples inside them.
We cannot examine all of them in detail. One emailer asked if my lab was poor and in a basement somewhere and another
person commented that I have been given all of the material I need to solve the mystery, but it is up to me to do so, I just need to hurry up and do some work.
Just to be clear, no, my lab is not in a basement. As for the poor vs. rich, that is a tough call. Rich labs have million dollar grants, and I do not have one of those, so maybe poor would be a better description of my labs financial status.
On the other hand, I amnot lacking for supplies and normal operational needs.
My lab personnel consist of my full-time lab technician, an undergraduate who volunteers a few hours a week and myself.
We are a small lab for sure. The small number of hands in my lab that are working on Morgellons is a factor in how much gets accomplished.
If we quickly examine the submitted samples and move on there is the risk of overlooking something important.
If we spend a lot of time on individual samples we keep getting the backlog of samples even further behind.
Trying to strike a well-balanced approach is not trivial and the time spent per sample is variable, depending on the nature of the sample.
I can only ask that people who have submitted samples be patient.
4) There are many ideas about the cause of Morgellons that have been forwarded to me.
Some of the proposals that people have sent me include:
a) springtails,
b) S. maltophilia,
c) Strongyloides, cutaneous larva migrans and nematodes in general
d) flukes,
e) parasitic nematomorphs from cotton,
f) engineered organisms (either industrial-strength that got into the environment or intentional bio-weapons),
g) extra-terrestrial,
h) ancient life-forms that escaped from an earthquake fault or volcano,
i) viral,
j) ‘other’ protozoans or parasites,
k) non-contagious genetic or environmental factors and l) dangerous dental work.
The bad news is that each of those ideas has proponents who feel they have proof for their idea. The good news is that the more specific and refined the idea, the easier to get evidence for or against the likelihood that it CAUSES Morgellons Disease.
There is a distinction here, which needs to be perfectly clear. If a person has non-healing lesions, is in a weakened state or has a compromised immune system, there are many organisms and parasites that may set up house in/on that person. I am not interested in those opportunistic organisms
.
I want to find the CAUSE of the diverse and often strange
symptoms of Morgellons Disease. The cause must explain all of the
varied symptoms including the production or appearance of the red, blue, clear and dark fibers, the black specks, the sand-like granules, the callous-like membrane, the peripheral neuropathy and the central nervous system changes.
When I am trying to PCR and then sequence DNA I must use a small stretch of known (or suspected) DNA called a primer. Primers can be very general or very specific. When we think something is bacterial, there are primers that can amplify and then be used for sequencing the DNA that will work on ANY bacteria known. These same primers are used to find new and previously unknown bacterial types.
The reason is that all bacteria, from the ones living in everyone’s small intestines to the exotic ones found in very novel locations, all share certain genes and stretches of DNA. Such primers are perfect for searching for unknowns that we grow in the laboratory from the fibers or scabs of Morgellons sufferers. But, if we think it is a specific organism, the primers can be designed that will ONLY amplify that specific DNA.
With that in mind, I feel that a) & b), springtails and S. maltophilia can be eliminated. The primers for the stretch of sprintail DNA will amplify a specific gene from over a thousand species of Collembola and yet we can never amplify this DNA from fibers, scabs, dried skin or callous material.
Even if the Collembola had been in contact with the scabs or the fibers it is likely they would have shed a few cells and that should be enough to amplify the Collembola DNA. Since that hasn’t happened, I consider it unlikely that Collembola are the cause of most of the Morgellons symptoms. Also, none of the Collembola proponents have explained to me where the fibers are coming from or why the neurological effects would make any sense from a Collembola infestation.
Similarly, in addition to the general bacterial PCR primers, we have S. maltophilia-specific primers and cannot amplify any DNA. I also do not think that the proponents of allergies to bad dental
adhesives/antibiotics have made a very strong case.
First, the sulfa drugs need to be at a high enough concentration to cause an allergic reaction & as a pharmacologist I find it hard to believe that such a concentration could ever be reached from sulfa-drugs leeching out over years and decades from the dental work. Second, some patients actually report some improvements while on sulfa-style antibiotics. Well, it can’t work in both directions; a person either is or is not allergic to sulfas, and the drugs will either cause the problem or help it.
Third, there are children who have never had any dental adhesives/ crowns/ caps on their teeth that have symptoms of Morgellons Disease.
Remember, I’m not trying to convince anyone of anything here. I have been asked to not be secretive and say some of what is on my mind. That is what I am doing here. This is NOT a position statement from the Morgellons Research Foundation. These are my personal thoughts and nothing more. I am trying to give you a glimpse of my thought process as a scientist.
I will address the Strongyloides and CLM proposals in a separate section. Most of the other proposed Morgellons causative agents are not easily testable, until a specific species is identified or suggested.
D-k in the above list all remain candidates. I’m not saying any specific ones are LIKELY, but from a scientific perspective, until they are eliminated (which won’t be easy for some of them) they remain candidates. There is also the possibility that a combination of the above may be necessary. There may be a genetic predisposition or a genetic protective component to Morgellons. Similarly, there may be certain environmental factors that trigger or repress the symptoms.
5) Some of you may have had the misfortune of receiving one or more vile, vulgar and belligerent emails from a person or two who claims to have figured out what causes Morgellons Disease and who is also kind enough to share that information, but only for the right price. The website in question claims that there really is no such disease as Morgellons and that it is nothing more than a combination of common parasites and nematodes. Specifically, Strongyloides is mentioned alongwith cutaneous larva migrans.
I would like to quote from this website (as of 4/12/06): “By the way, fibers are the shedding of their shell/ skeleton!” That is utter nonsense for multiple reasons. Nematodes/small worms/Strongyloides have neither a shell nor an internal skeleton or an exoskeleton. They have a multi-layered cuticle. Even if one wanted to make a point over semantics to give the benefit of the doubt to him/them it still makes no sense.
The Morgellons fibers cover a range in size from way tinier than even the smallest Strongyloides to several inches in length. The Morgellons fibers are not hollow, nor do they look like a split open cuticle. The red and blue fibers have no cellular structure or even ‘ghost’ outlines where the cells might have been. Many of you have probably spent more time looking in a microscope than I have. Most Morgellons sufferers that have looked at the fibers feel the term ‘fiber’ best describes their appearance. Small or large, red or blue they look like fibers. Also, published data suggests that Ivermectin will cure 97% of Strongyloides infections with a 2 day course of treatment. Some Morgellons sufferers have taken Ivermectin for weeks or months and few have reported that they are cured afterwards. There has been no DNA that can be amplified from the fibers that has been anything other than normal contaminating bacteria or in one case human female DNA, likely from cells of the person who submitted the fibers (it looked like there was a bit of bleeding & some white blood cells may have been the source of the human DNA). I do not know if the fibers are synthesized, shed or how they form, but they are not the shell/skeleton (which is impossible) or cuticle of Strongyloides. In an effort to be thorough, I will not completely reject the hypothesis that Strongyloides are involved in some cases of Morgellons.
I do, however, reject the idea that they are the CAUSE of Morgellons Disease. I will order PCR primers for Strongyloides and PCR from the scabs and fibers to see if there is any evidence of cutaneous larva migrans.
6) Some Morgellons patients have been fortunate enough to find kind and competent health-care providers. This is wonderful if it has been your experience. Unfortunately, many Morgellons Disease sufferers have not been treated in such a kind manner and have often been labeled as
delusional, without the benefit of a through physical examination. Many of you have been told, ‘stop scratching and you will heal’.
Well, while my ultimate goal is to find a cause and cure for Morgellons Disease, one of my short-term goals has been to convince a skeptical medical world that Morgellons Disease is not an internet-based subset of Delusions of Parasites.
Over the last 6-9 months, I have been accumulating data (really evidence) that SOMETHING really is going on here. That, this is not just a gigantic conspiracy, or herd hallucination by a group of delusional people. I have been convinced that Morgellons Disease is real for quite a while now. Every day that we do not find the cause of Morgellons Disease, it is not a waste of time. Because, practically every day we find more of the evidence that further confirms the reality that Morgellons is not DOP. Between emails & phone calls I am fielding questions from physicians, nurses and nurse practitioners, physician’s assistants and public health officials from state and city/county parish health departments. They all would like answers, which I cannot provide to them. Still, I think that most of them are willing to consider the possibility that Morgellons is real, and that is some progress.
There are those who refuse to discuss the science or evidence and are obsessed with the ‘impossibility’ of the symptoms of Morgellons. Most recently, I had a pathologist suggest that the fibers were being injected under the skin with a hypodermic needle and syringe. When it was pointed out to him that some of the lesions are on the back where a person could not possibly inject his- or herself, the pathologist had the obvious answer: the Morgellons patient was getting their husband/wife/child to inject into those hard to reach locations.
I was pretty amazed that he was able to even think up such a crazy idea, let alone think it more likely than the possibility that Morgellons was real.
7) What’s next for the research? Continue the search for any unusual/completely unexpected bacteria that are grown from fibers, scabs or other Morgellons material. A search for living organisms; eggs or immature forms of any parasites that might be involved in Morgellons. More spectroscopy of the fibers and chemical analysis to try to identify what the fibers are made of. Clinical faculty here at OSU-CHS will see patients for evaluation and sample collection, as well as identifying other health-care providers who want to participate in this research.
As soon as funding becomes available, an epidemiologist will begin her PhD studies in my lab by initiating a formal epidemiology study. We have bits and pieces of information but we really need this formal epidemiology study to help guide the direction of the clinical and lab-setting research.
Sincerely,
Randy S. Wymore, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor of Pharmacology & Physiology
Oklahoma State University
Center for Health Sciences and
College of Osteopathic Medicine
1111 W. 17th St.
Tulsa, OK 74107sa, OK 74107